As with any job you want to consider and compare availability, price, and quality. The first two are self-explanatory; you don't want to hire someone who won't show up or the one who charges more so you'll think it's worth more.Regarding quality, you want concrete that is both strong and cosmetic. That is achieved with proper mixing, placing, and finishing.
Mixing or "batching" is done at the plant and is likely consistent across the board, so this is not a concern. And the finished look is apparent, readily seen on the surface of the concrete. The most common flaw we see is "honeycomb" in the concrete. This is usually due to concrete insufficiently vibrated when placed. The result is voids and pockets in the concrete, seriously reducing the strength of the concrete.
Though the surface may appear smooth, the finished job is weakened and its life is shortened. Often clearly visible on exposed edges, many 'contractors' allow this because they hide the edge with dirt, sod, etc.